Americans Intensely Wary of Bailouts as Banking Concerns Mount: Poll

A bipartisan majority of Americans oppose U.S. taxpayers footing the bill when bad management causes a bank to fail, a Reuters/Ipsos poll completed on Wednesday found.

The poll’s results point to a potential political problem for Democrat President Joe Biden’s administration should the signs of shakiness in the U.S. banking sector worsen and prompt more aggressive government action.

The two-day Reuters/Ipsos poll found 84% of respondents – including strong majorities of Republicans and Democrats – think taxpayers should not have to pay to resolve problems caused by irresponsible bank management.

Many lawmakers, particularly Republican ones, have expressed similar sentiment in recent days, asserting that the president’s assurances notwithstanding, the aid to ailing banks represented a bailout that’d ultimately place burdens on taxpayyers and other financial institutions.

Biden said in a speech on Monday that taxpayers won’t suffer “losses” due to the bank’s collapse, noting that the money would be covered by the Deposit Insurance Fund which is paid into by banks.

“Joe Biden is pretending this isn’t a bailout,” Haley tweeted following Biden’s speech. “It is.”

She added, “Now depositors at healthy banks are forced to subsidize Silicon Valley Bank’s mismanagement. When the Deposit Insurance Fund runs dry, all bank customers are on the hook. That’s a public bailout.”

SVB Fallout

Stock markets have swooned around the world since Silicon Valley Bank collapsed on Friday as worried customers pulled their deposits. Two days later, New York’s Signature Bank closed. On Wednesday, U.S. stocks fell sharply as turbulence at Swiss banking giant Credit Suisse revived fears of a new banking crisis.

Banks have been stressed in recent months by rising interest rates, which reduce demand for borrowing money. In a series of moves telegraphed in advance to investors, the U.S. Federal Reserve, America’s central bank, has pushed interest rates higher over the last year in a bid to tame inflation.

Only 49% of Americans – 40% of Republicans and 55% of Democrats – said they favored government bailouts of financial institutions.

To be clear, support for bailouts was even more tepid a decade earlier, when the United States was emerging from a financial crisis which the government fought by spending hundreds of billions of dollars on bank bailouts.

In a 2012 Reuters/Ipsos poll, only 20% of Republicans and 53% of Democrats said they supported bailouts.

About half of respondents to the Reuters/Ipsos poll said they had heard at least a fair amount about Silicon Valley Bank’s implosion.

Sixty-eight percent said they had at least a fair amount of confidence in the stability of their own bank, and the same percentage had at least that level of confidence in banks more generally.

Some 77% of respondents said that shareholders and executives who profited from a bank in the days before it failed should have to return those funds to depositors.

U.S. regulators promised to make whole all depositors at Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank, even those with accounts above the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp’s standard $250,000 limit, without taxpayers having to cover any costs. Businesses make up many of the bank clients whose money had not been previously guaranteed by the government.

The Reuters/Ipsos poll showed broad bipartisan support for Washington backing bank deposits. Seventy-eight percent of respondents said the government should guarantee the deposits of individuals and 70% said Washington should backstop company deposits.

But a strong bipartisan majority also said depositors in banks should understand the risk of using a bank to make deposits outside of FDIC limits.

Some experts say the more expansive deposit guarantees regulators are applying for the troubled banks already amount to a bailout because they remove people’s incentive to guard against financial risk.

The Reuters/Ipsos poll, conducted online, surveyed 1,004 people nationwide and had a credibility interval of about 4 percentage points in either direction.